Most underrated game - Gaiden
Most overrated game - RE4
Most underrated character - Ark
Most overrated character - LEON FOR SURE!!!!!

I know my choices are a lot like Mass's but that's because we think the same way.

Underrated:Outbreak File #2 (Capcom ruined this series when they decided to cash out and try releasing the scenarios as seprate games instead of releasing them all in one game.)
Overrated: Code Veronica
Underated: I don't know...Carlos I guess
Overrated: Wesker

Underrated: Maybe the Outbreaks...

Overrated: How bout the Original RE's. Ha ha, or RE4. Actually RE4 and the Original RE's, those are all overrated.

Underrated: I always thought Chris might've been underrated. I mean he's got a following now, especially since RE5, but still. That's kinda something I always liked about him. He was a cool character, but not ridiculously overrated or anything.

Overrated: Wesker fo sho. Especially since they jacked his character up after Waugh's last role in RE4, starting with UC, through RE5 and DSC, thanks to Capcom and DC Douglas. Mister two initials and a last name jackass.

Otherwise obviously Leon, but I feel like that's died down a good deal.