Resident Evil 4 takes it for me. While I really liked 5, I love how the 4th had such a baddass feel. Leon was there to do a mission and was never gonna stop until they killed him. Chris was kind of like that but RE5 just seemed a little not baddass. I also like the ''over the top'' feeling that RE4 had, RE5 seemed to lack that for some reason. Though in all Dead Space beats both in my opinion, but I still voted for 4.

I don't think RE5 was better because I hate Leon. It's better because it does EVERYTHING RE4 does and does it better. Just because the 5 has the same gameplay from 4 doesn't mean 5 is bad. That's just dumb. 5 Even has a MUCH better story. Better music. Better voicing, at least the same quality. More weapons and upgrades. Better mercs. Online coop and versus. Better files and backstory info. And the epic 5-3 boss fight with Jill and Wesker and to me, an extremely emotional fight with Jill to get the injector off of her. I think the best music in the game is during that scene and compliments it very well.

Don't double post. Use the edit button in the top right. And survival horror is not about feeling badass. It should be the opposite. Though I felt much more secure and "badass" in 5 with my M500/Hydra combo plus the better melee mechanics. And the only over the top thing about 4 was the Salazar statue. But that was just dumb. Everything in 5 was over the top in a good way. Even Irving was an over the top eccentric.

You can count the sun lazer thing with the mirrors a puzzle. And even pulling the things to make the stairs change.

I thought that the puzzle in the dungeon of the castle in RE4 was a tough one but I aint good at those types of puzzles anyway

RE 5 is just a copy paste of RE 4 !!!!

YES IT IS , in many ways.

it's my own opinion.

Then Terminator 2 is just a copy/paste of Terminator 1. Yeah...try spouting that off at any Scifi convention. You'll be shot.

Relax Guys !!! in the end it's just a personal opinion !!??

what's the big deal !!!?